Alloy Steel and stainless steel are prevalent CNC machining materials in the contemporary fabrication market. Typically, both are composed of iron and carbon used in construction and defense and often share similarities to each. Steel gives peculiar features in machined products like strength, durability, versatility, and easy fabrication. When it comes to steel classification, there is constant competition between alloy steel vs stainless steel among product manufacturers. Deciding between these steel varieties depends on the features and knowledge of their applicability.
This article gives a detailed comparison of stainless steel and alloy steel. It defines them, their behaviors, and differences which helps you decide on which material to choose and which to avoid.
Overview of Alloy Steel in CNC Machining
Alloy steel can be described best as being a steel that comprises more than one alloying ingredient. Incorporation of these elements usually improves material characteristics, important for CNC machining. Basic steel is essentially iron with a small amount of carbon addition. In particular, chromium is added more often to increase corrosion protection among alloy steel. Other useful alloying constituents include vanadium, nickel, manganese, molybdenum, titanium, and tungsten apart from chromium. The selected components have a great impact on the characteristics of the alloy. For instance, the addition of manganese leads to improvements in the aspect of ductility as well as abrasion toughness.
Types of Alloy Steel Optimal For CNC Machining
Alloy steels are categorized based on their alloying element content:
High-Alloy Steels
These steels are characterized by more than 5% of one or more alloy constituents. They are highly resistant and strong. These constituents are manganese, chromium, vanadium, and nickel. Stainless steel best defines high-alloy steel, which contains a minimum of 12% chromium. This type is optimal for precision CNC machining, where corrosion issues are highly sensitive.
Low-Alloy Steels
Low-alloy steels entail a smaller quantity of alloying additives, the proportion of which does not exceed 5%. These steels improve strength and toughness, making them suitable for use under high pressure. Usual additions are tungsten, molybdenum, and copper. They are normally added to improve the mechanical properties of the steel, such as high strength, toughness, and weldability. Due to their strength-to-weight ratios, low-alloy steel is suitable for CNC-machined parts of mining and construction equipment.
Maraging Steels
Maraging steels are preferable to CNC machined in severe applications such as aerospace or military. These steels are particularly well suited to high-stress applications.
Tool Steels
Tool steels are particularly developed for use in CNC tool and die manufacturing. Due to their high alloy content, they have excellent wear, abrasion resistance, and hardness properties even at high temperatures and are thus used in CNC machining.
Overview of Stainless Steel in CNC Machining
Stainless steel contains at least 10.5% chromium to improve its ability to resist corrosion. This property makes it ideal for use in a broad range of CNC applications such as in the manufacturing of medical instruments and kitchen utensils. These factors make the product popular among manufacturers due to its uniqueness. However, stainless steel comes in different grades and each of the grades has specific features.
Common Types of Stainless Steel For CNC Machining
Although numerous stainless steel grades exist, they can be categorized as follows:
Austenitic Stainless Steels
Normally austenitic stainless steels have 8 – 20 % nickel and 17 – 25 % chromium. For instance, grade 304 includes 18 percent chromium and 8% nickel. These grades are nonmagnetic and extensively used in CNC machined parts such as food processing equipment and chemical vessels for preventing rust. Among them, grades such as 304/304L and 316/316L stand out because these alloys possess high strength, and good ductility and formability.
Martensitic Stainless Steels
Martensitic stainless steel contains chromium of 14-18% and carbon in the range of 0.2 to 2 %. These steels can also be tempered and hardened, ideal for CNC machining applications that need to strengthen parts such as cutting tools and surgical instruments. However, they show low ductility and poor weldability. The most popular ones are 420C and 431.
Ferritic Stainless Steels
Ferritic stainless steel has 11-27% chromium and less or no nickel content at all. They possess higher mechanical properties at high temperatures; their corrosion resistance is, however, inferior to that of the austenitic steels. They are ideal in terms of CNC machining of parts such as those forming automobile exhausts as well as specific architectural uses. Some common types are, for example, the 430 and 409 grades, which are mainly supplied as coils and sheets.
Duplex Stainless Steels
Duplex stainless steel has a Cr content of 18-28% and Ni content of 3.5-5.5% and has a microstructure of both ferrite and austenite. This composition enables high pitting and chloride stress corrosion resistance that fits them for CNC machining of components for use in extreme conditions like in oil sectors. Some of the recognized grades are 2205 and S32750 because they are weldable and possess higher corrosion resistance.
Precipitation Hardening Stainless Steel Grades
These grades normally have 12 to 16 percent chromium and 3 to 8 percent nickel besides copper, aluminum, and titanium. They are also characterized by high strength and elasticity and are widely used in CNC machining, where heat treatment is required. Applications such as aerospace parts and high-performance valves are some of the areas that get real value from these exceptional properties of the material.
Table: Technical Aspects of alloy steel vs stainless steel.
| Technical Aspect | Alloy Steel | Stainless Steel |
| Machining Tolerances | Typically ±0.005 inches for high precision. | Generally ±0.002 to ±0.005 inches for tight precision. |
| Precision Accuracy | High precision achievable, ideal for tools and structural components. | Excellent precision, suitable for detailed components. |
| Common CNC Machining Techniques | CNC Milling, turning, drilling, grinding. | CNC Milling, turning, laser cutting, waterjet cutting. |
| Surface Finish Options | Rough to fine finishes. | Often polished for aesthetic appearance. |
| Tool Wear Rate | Moderate tool wear; may require frequent tool changes. | Higher tool wear; specialized tools are often needed. |
| Thermal Conductivity | Higher thermal conductivity affects machining speed. | Lower thermal conductivity, requiring slower machining speeds. |
| Chip Formation | Chips are stringy and manageable during machining. | Tougher chips require careful handling. |
| Heat Treatment Process | Hardenable through quenching and tempering. | Annealing improves machinability and reduces stress. |
| Work Hardening | Minimal work hardening during machining. | Significant work hardening, impacting tool selection. |
| Weldability | Generally, good weldability varies by alloy content. | Excellent weldability, especially in low-carbon grades. |
Comparing Mechanical Properties of Alloy Steel vs. stainless Steel in CNC Machining
When comparing alloy steels vs stainless steels, the mechanical properties are of immense importance. While variations exist among different grades, here’s a general overview of their mechanical properties as they relate to CNC machining applications:
Tensile Strength
Tensile strength is a measure of how strong a material is before it succumbs to tension loads. Tensile strength for alloy steels ranges from 758 to 1882 Mpa. While for stainless steel, it ranges from 515 to 827 Mpa. This increased strength makes the alloy steels better suited for use in structural members in high-stress applications.
Hardness
Hardness measures a material’s ability to oppose wear and abrasion, depending on the material and heat treatment. Alloy steels have higher hardness scales of 200HB to 600HB (Brinell hardness) than stainless steels with 150HB to 300HB. Therefore, alloy steels are used for CNC machined components to be subjected to heavy wear and tear such as gears valves, and fittings.
Ductility
Ductility depicts a material’s capacity to change shape without fracturing. Overall alloy steels appear to be more ductile and hence suitable for CNC machining complex shapes with engineered features. This ability to be formed without cracking is especially useful in making thin-walled parts.
Impact Resistance
Stainless steels being materialistic are more prone to cracks in some situations, because of comparatively lower values of both hardness and toughness as compared to alloy steel. This characteristic makes alloy steels to be preferable for use in parts that will be under high stress.
Fatigue Strength
Fatigue strength determines the ability of a material to carry out load cycling over time. The fatigue strength of alloy steels is generally higher than that of stainless steels, therefore, the former is more suitable for applications in which a component is subjected to repeated loading. However, some grades of stainless steel such as the duplex exhibit superior fatigue strength because of their microstructure and are thus adaptable to use in CNC machining.
Corrosion Resistance of Alloy Steel vs. Stainless Steel in CNC Machining
Corrosion is a very important factor when comparing between alloy steel and stainless steel. Below is a summary of their corrosion characteristics relevant to CNC machining:
General Corrosion Resistance
Stainless steel is made to be incredibly corrosion-resistant. Chromium reacts with oxygen and thus develops a passive oxide layer of about 30-80 nm thickness. This layer hinders the formation of rust and for this reason, stainless steel is suitable in CNC machined parts usually exposed to moisture. By comparison with alloy steel, stainless steel normally does not require any further surface protection after processing, although the resistance can differ depending on the grade.
Pitting and Crevice Corrosion
Pitting and crevice types are common localized corrosion and can occur in stainless steel. Pitting is the result of diminishing the protective layer by chloride ions and surface deterioration. This issue is especially important for components that will be used in saltwater or harsh environments. Crevice corrosion occurs in narrow spaces, for instance, gaps in the joints where fluids and deposits are likely to form. While all types of stainless steel are susceptible, their chromium content makes them less vulnerable than alloy steel.
Galvanic Corrosion
Galvanic corrosion occurs when metals are connected, and immersed in an electrolytic solution. Alloy steel is somewhat more susceptible to corrosion because it donates electrons. Stainless steel being a noble electrochemical potential is not likely to undergo galvanic corrosion. Therefore, it’s recommended to avoid the usage of stainless & alloy or carbon steels in CNC machined assemblies.
Stress Corrosion Cracking
Stress corrosion cracking takes place under certain environmental conditions. Both alloy steel vs stainless steel are vulnerable mostly in acidic solutions. However, there is more resistance shown by ferritic stainless steels like 430 and 444 grades. Therefore, it’s imperative to select the right grade for CNC applications that can ensure stress as well as corrosive environments.
Heat Treatment and Fabrication Differences
Heat treatment improves the mechanical characteristics of alloy steel and stainless steel in equal measure. The following is a comparison of the heat treatment and fabrication processes of both materials.
Heat Treatment Processes
Annealing treatment increases the ductility of both types of steel. It involves heating the steel, holding it at temperature, and cooling it. Alloy steel is usually annealed at lower temperatures than stainless steel because it has a higher quantity of carbon.
Normalizing is applied to reduce internal stresses. One works the material at high temperatures and then cools it with air. Normalizing also depends on the component thickness in question.
The main goal of hardening is to improve the measure of strength at the cost of ductility. Carbon steels are difficult to harden because, during the cooling phase, the alloy steels undergo quenching as a result of relatively higher carbon content.
The process of tempering is to heat the metal to below upper critical temperature, soaking it for some time and then allowing it to cool in the air. The stresses are effectively relieved by this process which also lowers the brittleness and hardness as well.
Weldability
Alloy steel vs stainless steel are both easy to weld. However, stainless steel normally possesses higher weldability when compared to carbon steel because less carbon and chromium favors the formation of an oxide layer which has enhanced corrosion resistance. Nevertheless, weldability depends on the grade; for example, welding is not preferred for martensitic and duplex stainless steel.
Machinability
In general, stainless steel is less easily machinable than alloy steel and doesn’t have a good application in CNC machining processes. For instance, 304 Stainless steel has a machinability rating of 40%, while for alloy steel 1018, the rating is 78%. Some of the alloys, such as HSLA steel, may also show lower machinability.
Formability
Formability describes the ability of a material to deform without causing any harm to it. Depending on the type of stainless steel the formability can differ and in general, the martensitic types of stainless steel are the least formable. This characteristic determines how these materials can be worked on during the fabrication processes.
Applications Difference
Alloy steel and stainless steel work in different ways and within different markets for different reasons. Following are the common applications and selection criteria for each type.
Common Uses of Alloy Steel
Alloy steel is used in manufacturing settings that require superior strength and serviceability of the material in an application. Key applications include:
- Construction: Alloy steel is quite strong and used in structural elements in bridges, buildings, and pipelines.
- Automotive Industry: Common items like gears and axles along with materials like crankshafts usually contain alloy steel because of its resilience and steadiness.
- Aerospace Industry: Stress areas such as the undercarriage and turbine blades can be optimized by the properties of alloy steel.
- Tool Manufacturing: Reinforcement toughness and wear resistance characteristics make alloy steel applicable to CNC drills, saws, and milling cutters.
- Oil and Gas Industry: Manufactured from alloy steel, pipelines, and valves demonstrate high resistance to both temperature and pressure.
Applications of Stainless Steel
Corrosion and hygiene are the two areas where stainless steel performs well in industries. Common applications include:
- Kitchenware: Stainless steel utensils, cookery, and cutlery are preferred due to their ability to make food clean and free from stains.
- Architecture and Construction: Stainless steel is often utilized for the construction of building fronts and handrails because of its appearance and longevity.
- Medical Equipment: Biocompatibility and sterilization make stainless steel a valuable material in the manufacture of medical instruments.
- Automotive Industry: Mufflers, fenders, and yes, even some interior trims, employ stainless for its high resistance to rust or corrosion.
- Chemical and Petrochemical Industries: For reactors and storage tanks, stainless steel is used for lining because of its chemical and heat resistance.
Criteria for Selecting Between Alloy Steel Vs Stainless Steel
Selecting the appropriate steel for a CNC machining project involves several key criteria:
- Application: The specific application for which the material is being used to determine the properties needed.
- Properties: Determine the properties that are required depending on the use of the particular material. For mechanical applications, high strength is likely more important; for marine applications, corrosion resistance will probably be more important.
- Cost: Comparing the steel options in terms of their composition and their manufacturing method in a way that yields a more affordable, but otherwise satisfactory product.
- Availability: Evaluate material availability, for this can determine both the cost and time of manufacturing.
- Manufacturing Process: Select a manufacturing process for instance; CNC machining or sheet metal working, which may help to determine the soft hardness of steel and its ability to be processed.
Benefits of Alloy Steel when it is used in CNC Machining
Alloy steel offers several benefits for CNC machining applications:
- Scale Economy: In most cases cheaper and therefore can be easily incorporated into the budget.
- Higher Machinability: Improved machinability increases the accuracy when using Computer Numeric Control.
- Temperature Resistance: Resists deterioration at high temperatures may be experienced during the CNC machining process.
- Strength-to-Weight Ratio: A high strength-to-weight ratio is conducive to efficiency in design.
Advantages of using Stainless Steel in CNC Machining
Stainless steel also provides unique benefits for CNC machining:
- Aesthetic Appeal: Designs components for application with consumers.
- Low Maintenance: This is less complex and therefore does not need frequent servicing during its operations.
- Ductility: Higher ductility results in the possibility of the creation of complex shapes in the process of machining.
- Recyclability: It can be easily recycled thus supporting environmentally friendly fabrication.
Similarities Between Alloy Steel vs Stainless Steel For CNC Machining
Both alloy steel and stainless steel share essential characteristics relevant to CNC machining:
- Iron-Based Alloys: They are both made almost exclusively of iron and contain alloying material that affects the ability to machine the steel.
- Enhanced Properties: Other additives make it perform better; for instance, chromium increases wear resistance in both steels.
- Fabrication and Welding: Both materials provide fair fabrication and welding prospects, but, for some processes, alloy steel may be more suitable.
- Recyclability: Both materials can be recycled also making it possible to support sustainable parts production.
Prototeque: Get Affordable Solutions For Metal Fabrication
Do you want to source out your metal fabrication requirements? Prototeque offers premier quality solutions in stainless steel and alloy steel parts for various needs. As an ISO 9001:As an accredited provider of 2015, we employ state-of-the-art technology to provide quality parts at affordable prices.
Our engineering team pays close attention to your Design for Manufacture (DFM) to help you select the right fabrication processes for your project to succeed. We help you adjust product quality, modify component designs, and select surface finishes to fit your specific project requirements.
So, Upload your CAD today and get an instant CNC prototype price estimate and an extensive DfM analysis in minimal turnaround!
Conclusion
Alloy steel vs stainless steel are central materials, used in CNC machining; each has its strength, suitable for a specific type of application. Alloy steel is characterized by enhanced strength, easy machining, and relatively economical, which makes the material suitable for use in high-performance CNC parts. In comparison, stainless steel is seen as offering better corrosion properties and the ability to give products a shiny look especially where the finished product is being marketed to the consumer. Knowledge of these differences can go a long way to ensure that the right material choice is made for successful CNC machining projects.
